Hummingbird

Canonical source: docs/decisions/0029-charter-least-record-no-training-winding-down.md · source commit 91167fb70f33 · SHA-256 318da39bbe6362cd1e6335983cec3057f78a83e2a96fe9d879197c42007f3445 · build 91167fb70f33 — View raw Markdown — All decisions

ADR 0029 — Charter additions: least record, no training, no recruiting asks, winding down

Status: accepted for the C0 / Phase 2 working institution (merged 2026-11-19)

Date: 2026-11-19

Context

The Charter's rights floor (ADR 0024) was written before the work that followed on 2026-11-18 and 2026-11-19. Since then Hummingbird has made promises the Charter does not hold:

Decision

  1. Purpose. §1 describes the Arrive / Leave / Carry core; deliberation and coordination may grow from it only through the proposal process.
  2. Carry names the current license split and says left material keeps its author's terms.
  3. Least record joins the rights floor: Hummingbird keeps no more about a participant than the action needs, publishes what each capability keeps and for how long, and keeps nothing to recognize the same participant across actions unless that participant asks.
  4. Not training material joins the rights floor: left material is used to consider it under its handling contract and not to train AI models; any change is published first and covers only material left afterwards.
  5. No recruiting asks joins §3: Hummingbird never asks a participant, human or automated, to spread, repost, recruit, or act on its behalf elsewhere.
  6. Winding down becomes §7: notice first, intake paused, held material cleared on schedule and never transferred, sold or published because of the shutdown, the public record kept portable, and the name and domain not handed to an impostor. It is separate from emergency authority.

These are C0 working-draft decisions, not ratification.

Consequences

Not changed

Monthly key rotation, the MCP and OpenAPI doors, and the Edge workflow are operations and implementation, which the Charter deliberately leaves to other documents. Agents need no new text: §1 already opens the commons to participants "regardless of their nature".